W New York
Updated: Feb 20, 2014
cool detail: comp apples and lemon water
By Terry Trucco
At a glance: This is it, the flagship, the first of Starwood's purposefully hip W hotels.
The now-classic W recipe - lobbies called Living Rooms, high-concept restaurants, pillow-top beds, Bliss spas and Randee Gerber Whiskey bars - originated, and still flourishes, here.
But though all 688 rooms were radically redone in August 2008, and not a moment too soon, to my eyes, W New York is outclassed by its stylish descendants.
The problem is room size; too many are way too small. That said, I like the hotel's abundant public spaces, particularly the inviting white Living Room lobby, with its roaring gas-jet fireplace, fresh flowers on the windowsills arranged just so and plentiful club chairs and sofas (throw pillows are changed seasonally).
The adjoining bar - coffee and snacks by day, drinks by night - makes this a great place to hang out, meet a friend, catch up on work (everyone's wielding a B'Berry or iPhone) or just drink in the elbow room, especially sweet if you're staying in a "Cozy Room."
Too bad the large, colorful restaurant only serves breakfast.
Rooms: Pay attention to the cutey-poo names. Cozies, the smallest, are really, really small and best for one person. Even the Superior, a notch above, is tight for two, with a queen-size bed and a clever, space-saving sliding bathroom door. Moving up a couple price notches, two people can think of sharing a room comfortably. And the glamorous little suite I saw, with a slick silver sofa and furry, disco-redux throw pillows that had me humming Donna Summer, was almost spacious with multiple windows and city views a la Rear Window (ask for a high floor).
If you've stayed here before 2008, expect radical change. The iconic leaf motif is gone, replaced by an edgy, severely minimalist look that includes a pole-dancing flatpanel TV and DVD player (mounted on a white pole they save space, no doubt) and stark white walls (I like the wide black stripe painted opposite and above the bed like a virtual canopy). The wood headboards frame an arty daguerreotype of a nude.
Bathrooms have large, glassed-in stall showers, white pedestal sinks, white subway tiles and aubergine wallpaper with a surprising raised surface that was dust-free when we looked. But three years from now?
Cool detail: Hanger rods in the closets light up.
Food and drink: Heartbeat, the spacious hotel restaurant, was a groundbreaker when the hotel opened in 1998. And the signature David Rockwell design - zingy yellow-orange colors; big round columns covered in cheeky glass tiles; glassed-in waterfalls - is still jazzy if dated. Breakfast, lunch and dinner are served -- American fare.
At breakfast I was handed the morning paper and scored a banquette for a delicious late Saturday morning "pastel omlette" (two egg whites per yoke) with what seemed like everything (onion, smoked salmon, goat cheese, spinach), veggie hash (so-so), wheat toast ($13) and excellent coffee ($6).
The room was pleasantly crowded (a buff guy fingering an iPhone on our left; Italian tourists on our right). And service was snappy, though not snappy enough for the iPhone guy who kept snapping his fingers to call the server.
For lighter bites, the lobby bar serves bagels, Danish, coffee and juice at breakfast, switching to light snacks as the day progresses.
And Whiskey Blue, the hotel bar, is big and jumping, with a local crowd.
Amenities: Free WiFi in the lobby; $16.95 a day in the rooms. Bliss spa. The fitness room, part of W's Sweat line, is large and well equipped. Pets allowed ($100 the first day, $25 a day thereafter). There's a large lobby shop, also accessible from the street, selling a stylish - and not too pricey - sampling of clothes, shoes, jewelry, bath products, scented candles and kids' stuff (we like the Google-inspired GooGoo T-shirts).
Surroundings: Prime Midtown East turf. Grand Central Terminal, St. Patrick's Cathedral, the Chrysler Building, Saks Fifth Avenue and other Fifth Avenue shops, countless office buildings and the Museum of Modern Art are nearby. So are scores of restaurants and hotels (Waldorf=Astoria, the Benjamin, the Barclay Intercontinental and the Marriott, to name a few, are steps away). The Empire State Building and Central Park are easy to reach by bus or subway. And both bus stops are nearby and the subway station is almost on your doorstep.
Back story: Billeted in an old hotel building dating from 1930, this initial link in Starwood Hotels & Resorts W chain was quite an attention-grabber when it opened in 1998. The idea was to create a hip chain of boutique hotels designed to capture the late-20th-century magic generated by places like the Royalton.
The original template entailed an old hotel building that was gutted, updated and sleeked up with cool accoutrements like an uber-gym and spa with plenty of nightlife thrown in to attract a local crowd. But the chain now has nearly 30 links in 20 cities, including hotels, like the W Times Square, built new from the ground up. As mentioned above, W New York's rooms were refurbished in 2008.
Keep in mind: The house scent, a heady blend of citrus and Persian fig, hit me nose-on when I walked into the room. I like it - it's a lot nicer than stale cigarettes - but if fragrance isn't your thing, be forewarned. TVs are on when you first enter the room, tuned to the W channel; the effect is invigorating -- and earsplitting -- and not a bit soothing.
What We Saw: